The Man With No Outlines
At seven fifteen in the morning, the sun was soft in the sky. I’ve often woken as early as I can manage simply to watch the night sky turn violet first, as drops of daylight seep into the dark, spread, disturb its purity. But there’s nothing quite like the hours that follow, when everything gets saturated, slowly, with a new day. In Mumbai, if you happen to live close to the sea, there’s very little that can compare to watching night being harried out of a room by degrees. Its muggy warmth is upset, its color dispelled and its deep silence eroded bit by bit, by the unclasping of windows, birdsong, the creak of old bicycles, carrying a crisp sheaf of newspapers, trapped on the pillion.
That day, as per my new routine, I was out in the park, just beginning my rounds. The Colaba Sukh Sagar Park has a six hundred and forty meters long path that snakes through it. Almost every morning, the park is teeming with people. Trees, mostly banyans, surround you on either side. In the warmer months, the place is speckled with snow-white egrets. Varicoloured, expectant cats wait at the entrance, mewling, their eyes widening as you pass them by. In the sprawling park, somewhere, I heard someone say there’s a massive sundial.
That Tuesday, the crowd was scarce and scattered. Mid-August rains had dissuaded many from turning up. Those who had were careful not to run on the damp stone of the path. The usual smell of fish, which hangs in the air like an apparition, had grown prominent. The oldest park-goers, who were also the source of the loud, daily exhalations of “Om,” were missing. I could vaguely guess why. Monsoons, my late grandfather used to say, turned him into a creaking chair, his bones into a thing of music.
I had barely begun with my walk, covered some fifty meters when I noticed him sitting there.
Of course, I had seen him before. Twice, to be exact. Once, I’d seen him standing outside a store, lost in thought, maybe trying to make up his mind if he should enter. And another time, I had seen him from across the street, stooping, offering food to a cat. I couldn’t make out what it was, but the cat, raggedy, evil-looking, didn’t seem to enjoy it very much. It stalked away, the gobbet of food untouched, scarcely a moment or two before I did.
At the moment, he was sitting by himself on a park bench. The mellow, sweet flavor of the weather didn’t seem to have affected him in the least. He was glumly staring at his feet. He didn’t look happy about the entrancing color the sky had taken up, about the fact that we’d beaten the sun and rain to the park or about the dull but pleasant beat of life all around us.
Let me be clear. I am not some peppy extrovert. Far from it. I like being left alone, at times, and can empathize when someone desires a bit of solitude too. But the man on the bench didn’t fit the description of someone who wanted to be alone. And because I had heard of people like him, I knew that that was the last thing he could possibly want. And so, it was nothing but sympathy that drove me to upset my routine and approach him instead.
“Hello,” I said, walking over to him. He looked up.
“Okay if I sit here?”
Sure, he said. It was difficult to make out his tone. I’d heard that it takes a little while to get used to their way of talking. And it was my very first time meeting a Man With No Outlines.
Can you see that? The bird? he asked, all of a sudden, pointing at something.
At first, I couldn’t make out what it was he was indicating. Squinting, I finally did. It was amazing that he could see that far without any difficulty. Perhaps, I guessed, eyes that lacked specific shape and form, that were merely colors floating on a face, tended to be sharper than the ordinary pair. Maybe it was the one good thing about being who he was.
He had spotted a sparrow close to where the path started. From this distance, I would’ve been unable to spot it, if the people who entered the park didn’t keep stopping to look at it. Also, what helped greatly was the way it was thrashing about.
The sparrow was near the twisting roots of a banyan, one of many. Somehow, it had been caught badly in a riot of black thread. I decided, a second later, that it probably wasn’t some ordinary black thread but bitingly sharp kite string. Which made sense too. With the Independence Day having just gone by, the sky had been dotted with soaring, dipping orange, green and tri-colored kites. The poor bird must’ve had the misfortune, I imagined, of getting caught in a spare length of cut string left hanging from the old, shaggy banyan looming over it.
I could understand why the passersby chose to keep away from the sparrow. I, too, wouldn’t have been persuaded to set it free. The bird was putting up an enormous struggle. It was pecking mightily at the strings, fighting for its freedom, rolling to and fro on the wet grass. Even from where I sat, it was an impressive sight. It was also quite obvious that any thoughtful human hands that reached for the thrashing, determined sparrow would come away pecked, mercilessly, and bleeding.
I think I can help it, the Man With No Outlines said, distracting my attention.
“You can? So…what’s stopping you?”
The man looked at me. It was a sad, piteous look. I realized a little late that I had asked a very stupid question.
“I’m sorry. I didn’t mean—”
No, no, no, it’s okay, he said.
I felt worse now. I had begun to understand his tone. He had brushed off my apology quickly, almost eagerly. He didn’t wish to upset me. He needed me to be next to him. His desperation, his loneliness was painfully palpable. While I wanted to keep sitting there, for his sake, I simultaneously had begun to feel that it might’ve been a mistake coming over. I should have kept walking, done my rounds, gone home.
What do you do?
Again, this took me by surprise. He hadn’t told me his name or asked for mine. You exchanged names, perhaps talked about trifling things like the weather or the news, fostered some familiarity, and only then, I’ve come to learn, shifted to more personal topics. I had always thought that that was the order of all exchanges with a stranger. This novel approach made me somewhat uneasy.
“I…I’m a mathematician.”
I did not want to blurt this out. Had the conversation been more routine, I would’ve come up with a clever lie. But he had caught me off-guard and I spat out the truth. I grew worried that I’d made another terrible faux pas, accidentally humiliated him again. Thankfully, he chortled.
That’s funny, he said, grinning widely.
I felt relieved that he thought so. In my career, I’ve come to realize that Mathematics is a strong, suggestive word. It conjures an image the moment it’s spoken. Images that always connote the same things—decisiveness, form, structure, an endless array of lines, straight or curving, as if bent on a knee. Basically, everything he grotesquely lacked. I didn’t think for a second that the stark irony of the both of us sitting on that bench offered a choice, could be anything but hurtful. Apparently, it could be. It could be amusing.
My wife’s leaving me.
Another non-sequitur from him! I’ve had a lot of time to think about that bizarre un-conversation. There was no civilized flow to the way we talked that day. Flouting conventions so brazenly, I felt immensely self-aware that I was doing something wrong and desperately wished for it to stop. If only we weren’t being such adventurers, if only he would tell me his name, ask for mine in turn. Since then, I’ve had ample time to put together why he talked the way he did. The reasons, as they emerged, were quite uncomplicated really. He had been alone for so long that he’d forgotten how to talk to strangers. For all I know now, he might’ve been doing his very best to sound “normal.” But these realizations are a result of years of idle contemplation and hindsight. Right then, I just considered all of it unnatural and a bit odd.
“I’m sorry to hear that,” I said honestly.
He shook his head. I cannot blame her. I’m grateful that she stayed as long as she did. She’s my dearest, my only friend. Was. I think that’s why she stayed as long as she did. Not because she was my wife, but because she was my friend.
I saw an opportunity to rein in this wild conversation here and took it before he could surprise me again.
“If she already knew she’d leave you eventually, why did she marry you?”
We married long before…long before all of this…
“Oh. I thought—”
That’s what everybody thinks at first, he said, nodding. All the colors on his face moved, seeped into each other, blended with one another to form new, garish shades. But no. I wasn’t born this way. None of us are. I used to have a chemist shop in Worli. Years ago. I loved having a daily schedule, a waking time, a time to sleep, to eat, of going to work. All of that is gone.
“So, when did it—”
Happen? he finished, eager to talk, to unburden an old load. I—I cannot remember “everything.” But I have these—these distinct memories of being a happy, organized man. I was the kind of person who would stop to admire a desk or a chair for its purposefulness. I had a fascination for old things, especially radios. The more clunky and broken and the more knobs missing, the better! My wife and I, we had a decent life together and we cherished it thoroughly. Kyurvi, my wife, taught Geography in a school, back then, to grades four and five. That might not seem like much to you, a mathematician, but she suffers from a terrible lisp. She had to give it her all to get that job. Both of us, we worked hard, didn’t have much money, but we had the basic things we needed, and that felt more than enough. We felt blessed.
“That sounds good,” I said.
It was, he said. Our very own little paradise.
“So, again, I don’t understand. What happened?”
The Man With No Outlines remained quiet for a beat. Then he spoke more quietly than before. Even though I had grown accustomed to his manner of talking by now, this time I had to strain to listen.
It happened one day. I had drawn the shutter down on the shop and was waiting at the bus stop. I had closed up early and would have to wait some fifty minutes for the bus that took me from Worli to my flat in Thane. I cannot tell you where or how the thought entered my mind, but as I stood, waiting, at some point something hit me with great force. It was Doubt. It came out of nowhere. I wish there was some dramatic episode, some epiphany, you know, that brought it on. There wasn’t. I was standing at a normal bus stop. And it—it found me.
The Man With No Outlines nodded slowly, grimly.
I went home puzzled and told myself that things would be better the next day. They weren’t. They got worse. Kyurvi, my wife, noticed on the third day. My employees at the shop on the fourth. On the fifth day, two of the three didn’t turn up for work. As superstitious as they were, they didn’t even return to collect their salaries.
As he kept talking, I felt a new, utterly unfamiliar disquiet, almost a panic, start to creep up on me. He’d said something that truly frightened me and sent a quick chill down my back. The bit about Doubt. Constant Doubt was a state that had existed throughout my life. It lived in the back of my mind, buried deep under lists of chores, worries, hopes, more. As he spoke about it then, I felt things, weightless things, move, budge, rise in me. I was struck by an unknown terror.
Once Doubt had a strong enough hold, he carried on, it started showing up all over me, changing me, by and by. My definiteness, my outlines began to disappear. And once they did, people, those closest to me, realized what was happening and immediately distanced themselves. Friends I’d grown up with refused to take my calls or even speak to me when I turned up at their door.
I wanted him to stop talking. Right then. Just stop. I tried speaking. “I need to—” I muttered lowly, but he barreled on, airing what he’d kept bottled up for too long.
Suddenly, I found simple things impossibly difficult. I had this—this ever-expanding uncertainty. About everything! Over time, my voice changed. People don’t realize this, but a voice, its tone too has shape, an outline. My lips were the last to lose their form; they became this melting red mess you see. People started staring at me, just staring blankly, and they looked away the second I tried approaching them. I felt judged at all times. I still do. At all times.
“I need to go. I’m sorry, but I need to go right now!” I finally said, shaken up, jumping to my feet.
I wish he’d created a scene right then. I would’ve deserved the humiliation. Something overwhelmingly dramatic. Clung, with building intensity, onto the one person in perhaps ages who’d shown him some kindness. But he kept silent and hung his head. That, as I stalked off urgently, selfishly, made me feel woeful and horrible inside. Regardless, I knew I needed to get away from him as soon as I could, because everything he’d said had made complete sense to me. What was worse was that it had stirred something in me.
I had walked only a few steps from him when I felt the slightest pinch of something on my hand. I brought it up to see what it was. And when I did, all breath was knocked out of me, as if I’d taken a punch in the stomach.
The nail on the ring finger of my left hand was different. Its outlines had entirely vanished. Its colors were running, leaking into the skin of my finger. Fear, total and formidable, stilled my heart. It scurried in me like something from a trap. It was an unmistakable symptom. Of the inevitable things and time to come.
I’m not fanatical about my health. I had only taken to the morning walks at the behest of my family doctor. My knees, you see, had been giving me trouble of late. Pointing at my X-rays, Dr. Makhija explained that, eventually, I would have to get knee-replacement surgery, get new, artificial joints planted like seeds. To help me along, for the time being, he stuck a long needle into my knee—a procedure I wouldn’t wish upon my worst enemy—and, grinning devilishly, drew out a syringe full of brown, murky, foul-smelling liquid. Then, when, shortly, relief flooded my legs and pried away the pain, he advised me on the walks. But he strictly warned me against running, as that could further damage both the ruined joint and its surrounding tissue.
When I saw the fingernail and what all it implied, first, I spun back to the Man With No Outlines. However, he looked so miserable sitting there, so unreservedly wretched, any rage that had sparked in me against him flickered out instantly. I lingered there for only a few seconds longer. And then, ignoring all sound medical advice and the protests that rose from my knees seconds later, I ran.
The only desire that remained in me was to hasten home to my wife. To get under the bedsheets again and nudge awake a sluggish, drowsy Anuva. To ensure, at that early hour, that she still loved me. To lightly insist she say it out loud, repeat it a couple of times. And all that time, I would be holding my hand behind my back like a child with a secret, making sure she didn’t see.
As I ran from the park, the few who still remained watched me, intrigued. I wasn’t jogging, I was sprinting. Like something crazy. But even in that mad rush to get home, I didn’t fail to notice the sparrow near the start of the winding path. The defiant thing had finally pecked itself free of the kite string.
As I tore past the gate and into the street, the sparrow rose up too, above me, beating its thin wings, its cry triumphant, joyous. A woman, her hair in plastic curlers, leaned out of her window, crossing her arms on the sill. People began to materialize in the street, gather near sabzi-wallahs, bark raucous laughter. School-bound children, lugging heavy bags, came pouring out of buildings. Soon, the strays grew unafraid to bark, to shatter what remained of the stillness.
About the Author
Tushar Jain was the winner of the 2012 Srinivas Rayaprol Poetry Prize, 2013 Poetry with Prakriti Prize, 2014 RL Poetry Award, 2014 DWL Short Story Contest, and 2016 Toto Funds the Arts Award for Creative Writing. His work is published (or is forthcoming) in various literary magazines and journals, such as aaduna, Papercuts, The Nervous Breakdown, Antiserious, RaedLeaf Poetry India, Young Ravens Literary Review, Lowestoft Chronicle, The Madras Mag, Coldnoon, Streetcake Magazine, Sierra Nevada Review, Into the Void Magazine, The Cape Rock, Miracle, Dryland, The Bookends Review, Edify Fiction, Gramma, decomP, Priestess & Hierophant Press, Barking Sycamores, Literary Heist, The Wax Paper, The Wagon Magazine and others. He lives and works in Mumbai.